Helping Low-Income People of Color Achieve Financial Sustainability
About
My team collaborated with Citi Ventures to address the issue of financial inequality through product and service design within a span of 15 weeks
My Role
• Conducted secondary research, user interviews, and expert interviews
• Turned the insights from research into viable design ideas
• Crafted an overall brand system, style guides, and component libraries for the team
• Created high-fidelity user interfaces and made all design decisions for all screens
Company
Citi Ventures
Timeline
Sep - Dec 2021
Team
4 Designers (incl.me)
Original Challenge Prompt
How might we (Citi) develop an innovative fintech product that increases racial equity, expands financial inclusion, and empowers people of color?
Process
We developed our product through the following four phases
We moved back and forth among the four phases as the design process was not linear. We needed to go back and redefine our project scope while learning more about our given problem statement.
Problem Space
Low-income people of color often rely on costly non-traditional financial services that don't help their credit
We visited the Bronx area to understand our target users better. While exploring, we noticed many check cashing services, which are less common in central Manhattan. These services enable people to cash their paychecks without a bank account but charge high fees.
$189 billion
Financially underserved customers in the U.S. spent $189 billion annually in fees and interest
2X
Households of color are two times more likely to have used check-cashing services and money order as compared to white households
Financial Health Network, 2018
Why does it matter?
Many of our user's long-term financial goals are to own a house, get a better car, or even start a business. All of these goals require a good credit score.
Own a House
Get a Better Car
Start a Business
All of these goals require
'Good credit scores'
Revised Challenge Prompt
How might we help low-income people of color build or improve their credit scores so that they can plan and make progress towards their long-term financial goals?
User Research
We conducted 10 in-depth stakeholder interviews
We conducted 6 semi-structured interviews with target users and 4 expert interviews (including community experts and banking representatives) to understand how low-income individuals manage their finances, the challenges they encounter, and how we can offer assistance.
To further understand the users’ financial situation and needs, we tried an activity using Likert Scale during the interview.
After the user interviews, we wrote down transcripts immediately and then moved to the empathy map to highlight the key insights.
Interview Highlights
Why don't low-income people of color use traditional banking services?
Lack of trust in banks
“I only put 50% of my money into the bank, not 100%. What if they just take it?”
Wayne Simpson 34, Staten Island, New York
Negative financial habit
“I don’t use my credit card now because it has already maxed out.”
Shavonna Conyers 33, Bronx, NY
Language barriers
“I am not fluent in English so I don't understand the information that is given to me in English.”
Lois Pine 30, Brooklyn, New York
Other reasons
• Had negative banking experience in their home country
• Unable to meet minimum balance requirements
Ecosystem map
Ecosystem map to determine complicated relationships between influential actors and users
With help from the financial experts we interviewed, we were able to better understand the complicated relationships between various actors who possess social, financial, informational influences on the user.
Click on the image to enlarge
Brainstorming and Prioritizing Ideas
Brainstorming
Based on four design principles, we brainstormed potential features to address the challenges users face: how to sign up with minimum identification requirements, how to create a personalized plan, how to engage in the online community forum, and how we can provide financial resources.
Style Guides & Component Library
Promised design guidelines to ensure product consistency and enhance team work efficiency
I solely created an overall brand system, style guides, and component libraries for the team. This successfully resulted in consistent product design and improved work efficiency within the design team, all within a limited timeline of 3 weeks for the final pitch to Citi Ventures.
The image above represents a small part of the design elements I've created. There are many more components and patterns, including accordion, card UI, toasts, and data visualizations.
Final Deliverables
Transitioned from IA to prototypes
Due to time constraints, the team quickly shifted from information architecture to mid-fidelity prototypes. We efficiently developed mid to high-fidelity prototypes by leveraging pre-defined style guides and component libraries that I provided. I designed all screens and made every design decision for the screens presented below.
Accessibility
Support multiple languages & minimum identification requirements
When signing up, users gain access to the online community forum and resources without the need to provide personal or banking information.
Accessibility
Assistive tools: translation, financial dictionary, bookmark
Users can access assistive tools to translate, search a dictionary, and bookmark words or sentences for further learning by simply tapping with a finger.
User-Centeredness & Cultural Competence
Ask personalized finance questions anonymously
Users can feel much safer asking their finance-related questions because it's anonymous, and Finana provides tips to ensure they receive high-quality answers.
User-Centeredness & Cultural Competence
Receive professional advice from trusted financial advisors & community experts
Receive professional advice from trusted financial advisors and community experts, as well as assistance from other users through shared experiences.
Accessibility
Learn financial jargon in a more digestible way
Users can easily figure out difficult financial language through easy examples and related lessons.
Trust & Empowerment
Create a personalized financial plan unique to each user’s situation
Personal or banking information is only required for users who wish to utilize a personalized financial planning service to achieve their long-term financial goals. However, users will be informed about our transparent data collection policy.
Financial Sustainability
Achieve long-term financial success
Users can easily track their current financial situation and achieve long-term financial success by breaking down goals into actionable steps.
Financial Sustainability
Recommend the best financial advisor and product for you
Finana provides users with recommendations based on their financial situation and credit score to assist them in achieving their goals.
Takeaways
Defining project scope and initial steps
It took us a significant amount of time to define our project scope. We had to take into account various factors that users face, such as unpredictable income and living situations. However, laying out the entire user journey, from the user's current financial standing to where they aim to be in the next 5-10 years, proved beneficial for the team. It allowed us to identify the initial steps we could take to assist them on their journey.
A new try, co-design workshop
We hosted co-design workshops, and initially, I doubted how beneficial they would be as it was my first time. However, I soon realized my misconception. I gained insight into users' priorities regarding ideas generated during brainstorming sessions in the workshops and had the opportunity to receive honest and detailed user opinions. It proved to be an invaluable tool for validating assumption-based solutions for users.
Next step
Come up with a new product name
Our product name, Finana, was inspired by one of our users in co-design workshops. However, after the final presentation, we received feedback saying that it might not be appropriate to use a banana to symbolize a product directed towards the African American community. Therefore, even though it's unintentional, it's important not to cause any confusion or misunderstanding.
Special thanks to:
Qualitas of Life
Non-profit organization that provides financial education
Raven L.Veal
Strategic Design Lead at Citi Ventures
Jennifer Shuang
Head of UX Research at Citi Ventures
Melvin Washington II
Racial Equity, Data, and Technology at Citi Ventures
Misty Bell Stiers
VP, Creative Director - Inclusion at Citigroup
Kaitlyn He
UX Designer
Lucy Zhang
First Vice President at Royal Business Bank
Next
©2024 Ted TAEhyun Lee. All rights reserved.